Visa reason code 13.1: "product not received" — the evidence that wins
Visa reason code 13.1 covers "merchandise/services not received": the cardholder says they paid and the goods never showed up. When your carrier delivered the order, this is one of the most winnable disputes in ecommerce — and one of the most commonly fumbled, because the proof is scattered across a tracking page, an inbox, and an order system.
The exhibit that carries the case
One piece of evidence outweighs everything else: a carrier delivery scan showing the package delivered at the customer's checkout address, with the timestamp. "Shipped," "out for delivery," and "label created" prove nothing about receipt. If you have only one thing, get this.
Build the rest of the packet around it:
- Exhibit A — Delivery proof. The carrier tracking record showing delivered status, the delivery address, and the delivery date/time.
- Exhibit B — Order confirmation. The confirmation showing the customer ordered the item to that same address. This closes the "wrong address" escape hatch.
- Exhibit C — Delivery photo. If your carrier captures one, include it. It corroborates Exhibit A at a glance.
- Exhibit D — Shipping-timeframe disclosure. The delivery estimate or shipping policy as it appeared on your product page or at checkout on the order date — useful when the complaint is really "it arrived later than I hoped."
- Exhibit E — Customer communications. Any message where the customer discusses the delivery, asks where the package is, or acknowledges receipt. This often ends the argument.
Structure the response like this
- Summary (3–5 sentences). Name the reason code, the strongest fact, the dates: "Visa 13.1. Carrier tracking (Exhibit A) shows the order delivered to the checkout address on Mar 3 at 11:42 a.m. The customer first contacted us Mar 10 and was offered a free replacement the same day (Exhibit E)."
- Timeline table. Order date → shipped → delivered → first customer contact → dispute filed. Analysts scan this in seconds.
- Exhibits, in reading order. Every claim in the summary points at one exhibit; no orphan attachments.
Mistakes that lose winnable 13.1s
| Mistake | Why it loses |
|---|---|
| Submitting a tracking link instead of the delivery record | Analysts work from your packet, not your carrier's website. If the delivered scan isn't in the evidence, it may as well not exist. |
| "Shipped" proof only | Proves you sent something, not that the customer received it. 13.1 is decided on receipt. |
| Linking to today's shipping policy | Issuers can tell when a policy changed after the purchase. Use the version shown at checkout on the order date. |
| Responding on day 20 of a 14-day window | An automatic loss, however perfect the packet. Deadline alerts exist because this is the most common failure of all. |
The economics
With Stripe, a dispute costs $15 when it opens, plus another $15 if you fight and lose — so a delivered-order 13.1 with a clean delivery scan is usually worth fighting, while a genuinely untracked shipment may not be. Be honest about which case you have; banks decide, and no tool can guarantee a reversal.
Have a 13.1 open right now?
Parry assembles this packet from your uploads — dispute notice, tracking, invoice, customer messages — into a case summary, rebuttal draft, timeline, and labeled exhibits. It's an AI draft: you review every fact and submit it yourself. We never submit in your name, never invent evidence, and the outcome is always the bank's call.
$10 for your first month, then $29/mo. Up to 5 evidence packets/month, dispute deadline alerts, and a saved store/evidence profile. Cancel anytime. No success fee.
Parry is not affiliated with Stripe or Visa. Reason-code descriptions are general information, not legal advice; your processor's dispute notice controls deadlines and requirements. Last updated: October 9, 2026.